During Harry's detentions with Umbridge in OotP, Umbridge forces Harry to magically carve the words "I must not tell lies" into the back of his hand with a Blood Quill. In the book, Harry suffers silently, not wanting to give Umbridge the satisfaction of seeing him complain and not wanting to talk to Dumbledore due to being angry at him for keeping Harry in the dark, and lets her continue her reign unchallenged.

You are watching: Harry potter fanfiction mcgonagall finds out about the blood quill

...But what if he told a trusted adult about what Umbridge was doing, like Professor McGonagall and/or Dumbledore, and took one of them (or anybody else) with him under the Invisibility Cloak? Even with the jackass attitude the Ministry has in this book, surely they wouldn't be able to get away with mutilating children, right?

I should note that I've read something like this where it's Hermione who blows the whistle, and I thought it was pretty in-character for Hermione, but I'm looking for something where Harry tells one of his professors about it.


5 comments
share
save
hide
report
100% Upvoted
This thread is archived
New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast
Sort by: best


*

level 1
· 10m
I forget the title, but there was one I read into where Harry did blow the whistle and it made things so much worse. Instead of punishing Umbridge for torturing children, the Ministry said that Harry did that to himself, which was simply more evidence of how disturbed and unhinged he was. Now that he was self-harming, he obviously needed to be committed to a secure, isolated cell in Saint Mungo's. It was more than a bit dark.


6
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 10m

Sirius finds out in linkffn(9562487) and is FURIOUS

This one linkffn(13643298) Tonks impersonates Harry to gather evidence against her.

This one linkffn(5681042) Harry and Dumbledore set up a recording device and catch her in the act.

See more: Sorry This Feature Isn T Available Right Now, Sorry, This Feature Isn'T Available Right Now


3
Share
ReportSave
level 2
· 10m
Bot issues? PM /u/tusing

Taking Control by daily-chan

What if Sirius had learned about the Blood Quill and wanted answers, going to Hogwarts to get those answers. Warnings for strong language, Umbridge and Dumbledore bashing and possible OOC-ness. Rating is for possibly considered strong language. Part of the A Bond of Family series

Quidditch Tales by potterlad81

Fifth year isn't going great for Harry until a teammate catches him hiding an injury. Katie Bell gets the ball rolling, but Harry's the one who picks it up. A few new friends can go a long way to fixing Harry's problems.

Site: fanfiction.net | Category: Harry Potter | Rated: Fiction M | Chapters: 24 | Words: 158,140 | Reviews: 74 | Favs: 667 | Follows: 366 | Published: 7/14 | Status: Complete | id: 13643298 | Language: English | Genre: Drama/Romance | Characters: P., Katie B.> Sirius B. | Download: EPUB or MOBI

Heart and Soul by Sillimaure

The Dementor attack on Harry during the summer after his fourth year leaves him on the verge of having his wand snapped. Unwilling to leave anything to chance, Sirius Black sets events into motion which will change Harry's life forever. HP/HG/FD