Sorry to step in, however this question puzzles me also... simply as a issue of clarification, have the right to we say that 'are you done?' is comparable to 'have you finished?' yet the initially one is usually complied with by with + noun or -ing form, and the second by object or ing form? Thank you in advance!
"Are you done" asks around whether you have finished somepoint that you have began. "Have you done" likewise asks if you have finiburned, however whether you have also began is unspecific.
You are watching: Are you finished or are you done
("Are you done" deserve to likewise be used in a "correcting" or "accusatory" way, wbelow the asker knows full well you haven"t started and that is the suggest he is trying to make. But that is not the normal instance.)
When asking "Have you done?", you are asking if the perchild did something in the previous which could proceed to the present or have actually some effects to the present.
"Are you done?", on the other hand also, actually means "have actually you finished?". That is, you are asking if the perkid completed the action started in the past (even though such activity may additionally have actually implications to the present).
See more: How To Take A Screenshot Nexus 6P, Guide For The Huawei Nexus 6P
"Are you done" is used as soon as asking a perkid if he or she has finiburned doing somepoint. The point that is being done is recognized.
Are you done with washing the toilet?
"Have you done" is asked once the point being done is not well-known, and the perchild is inquiring as to what the thing is.
What specifically have you done to my car?
So, if you want to ask if someone has finished doing something, used "are you done?", or "have actually you finished?" , but not "have actually you done?"
Use "have you done" when asking around something that has taken place, and also you do not understand. e.g. What have actually you done to him?
Improve this answer
edited Jul 13 "11 at 2:12
answered Jul 13 "11 at 1:54
40.4k4242 gold badges160160 silver badges238238 bronze badges
Add a comment |
Highly energetic question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation necessity helps protect this question from spam and non-answer task.
Not the answer you're looking for? Browse various other questions tagged grammar differences present-perfect present-tense or ask your very own question.
Featured on Meta
what is the interpretation of,Are you done?
How execute the tenses and also aspects in carolannpeacock.com correspond temporally to one another?
How to use "have been" and be-verbs -- what's the distinction between them?
"For exactly how many kind of days have actually you been there?"
"didn't must have actually done" or "needn't have actually done"
"Did you do it?" vs "Have you done it?"?
Are “Why did you perform that” and also “Why have you done that” interchangeable?
What are the differences between determination and also motivation?
What is the distinction in between Desire and also Will?
Hot Netjob-related Questions even more hot concerns
Subscribe to RSS
Concern feed To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader.
carolannpeacock.com Language & Usage
Stack Exreadjust Netoccupational
site style / logo © 2021 Stack Exreadjust Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.9.10.40187